Arsenal 1–1 Chelsea: VAR Debate Overshadows London Derby as Blues Equal WSL Record
It was only a week ago that Chelsea celebrated captain Millie Bright’s 300th appearance for the club, but the Blues had another milestone to mark at the Emirates. A 1–1 draw against Arsenal means Chelsea have equalled the Women’s Super League record for the longest unbeaten run, 33 matches, a record first set under Emma Hayes between 2019 and 2021.
With Hayes, now manager of the U.S. national team, watching from the stands alongside Arsenal legend Vic Akers, the stage was set for another fierce London derby. What followed was a match of breathtaking quality, controversy, and frustration, a game that reignited calls for VAR in the WSL.
Sonia: "Aggie played the London City game last weekend, she was fine but after the game, she didn't really recover the way we wanted to from her dead leg. So she has basically a collection of blood in her leg and she can't bend her knee the right way, so this is why we didn't want to take any risk with that today. We still have a chance (to have her back) for the midweek game, probably more on the next weekend against Liverpool."
This game was the first time women’s football had two £1 million players on the pitch.
First Half: Thompson’s Magic Moment
Chelsea made a bright start and came inches from scoring within three minutes when Johanna Rytting Kaneryd’s strike hit the post. The breakthrough came soon after and it was spectacular.
A day after her 21st birthday, Alyssa Thompson marked her first WSL start with a moment of brilliance. The American picked up the ball on the right, darted inside, and lofted a sublime finish over Arsenal keeper Daphne van Domselaar from the edge of the box. It was a world-class goal that left the Emirates stunned and justified Chelsea’s near-£1 million summer investment.
Chelsea dominated the early stages, with Catarina Macario forcing a sharp save and Erin Cuthbert dictating play. Arsenal, however, began to find rhythm before halftime, with Caitlin Foord and Beth Mead combining dangerously on the left and Beth Mead’s corners testing the Chelsea defence.
But at the break, it was still 1–0 to the champions deservedly so.
Second Half: Arsenal Fight Back Amid Controversy
Arsenal came out stronger after the restart, dictating play and pushing Chelsea deep into their half. The Gunners thought they’d levelled when Stina Blackstenius smashed home from a corner, but the referee ruled the goal out for handball. Replays were inconclusive, but without VAR in the WSL, the decision stood and the Emirates erupted in disbelief.
Tempers flared. Katie McCabe and Caitlin Foord were booked for dissent after surrounding the official. Then came one of several flashpoints that defined the match: McCabe’s studs-up tackle on Lucy Bronze, which left the Chelsea defender clutching her shin in pain. Bronze managed to continue, but many believed McCabe was lucky to stay on the pitch.
Moments later, Victoria Pelova lunged late on Keira Walsh, catching the Chelsea midfielder badly. Walsh was left wincing, and according to BBC Live Text commentary, Pelova would likely have been sent off if VAR had been in use. Yet again, the officials chose only to show a yellow card.
Despite the chaos, Arsenal finally found a way through when Alessia Russo reacted quickest to a loose ball and powered home her 50th WSL goal, levelling the score and sparking huge celebrations. But controversy lingered, replays suggested Russo might have been marginally offside.
Then, deep into stoppage time, Frida Maanum dinked home what appeared to be a dramatic Arsenal winner, only to see the offside flag raised again. The Gunners’ fury was unmissable; the Emirates crowd responded with boos as the full-time whistle confirmed another controversial WSL classic.
Post-Match Reactions
Arsenal head coach Renee Slegers was diplomatic but firm about the need for progress.
“A lot of respect for referees because it’s not easy,” she said. “We’re looking at a video. If you ask me, we need justice and that’s why I think VAR and technology can help.
I don’t want to elaborate too much, but there’s more and more at stake in the WSL. We have to have a look at how we grow the game in all aspects.”
Chelsea boss Sonia Bompastor echoed her counterpart’s call for technological support.
“I think bringing technology into the women’s game would be probably the best call we can make,” the Chelsea manager said. “It’s difficult to make comments on it because from the dugout you can’t see the same as they can see on the pitch. I probably can understand that Arsenal feel a little frustrated, but I don’t want to make any comments. I’m not the referee and I was too far away to make a really good comment. I haven’t watched the game again yet.”
Bompastor added that she wasn’t overly concerned by Chelsea’s position in the table, with Manchester City threatening to overtake them.
“We always want to be the leaders, but the most important thing is to be leading at the end of the season. I trust in my squad the quality we have will allow us to do that.”
Arsenal striker Alessia Russo, who equalised for her side, didn’t hide her frustration.
“Really disappointed not to take all three points,” she told Sky Sports. “I think we deserved to win and I think some of the goals we scored were wrong decisions. I know referees have a tough job, but I’m disappointed not to take all three points.”
Chelsea midfielder Erin Cuthbert reflected on a derby that was as emotional as it was controversial.
“It was a proper derby, physical, emotional, and full of quality,” she said. “But the refereeing decisions left everyone confused. We just want consistency. Both teams deserved better from the officials tonight.”
Speaking on Sky Sports, former England international Izzy Christiansen was even more direct, describing the refereeing as “absolutely abysmal.”
“It costs them. There’s no other way to put it they have been robbed,” Christiansen said, adding that the decisions could have “a serious impact on Arsenal’s title challenge.”
VAR in the WSL: Needed, But Not Easy
The calls for VAR in the WSL are growing louder after yet another weekend of controversy. Coaches, players, and pundits agree: technology is needed to ensure justice and consistency. But introducing it is not as simple as flipping a switch.
Financial and Infrastructure Barriers: The FA’s women’s professional game director, Kelly Simmons, has confirmed that the delay in VAR implementation comes down to cost and infrastructure. Not every WSL ground meets the standards required full VAR needs multiple calibrated cameras and suitable broadcast facilities.
Discussions Underway: The PGMOL, the body overseeing referees, has explored introducing a cheaper “VAR-light” model with fewer cameras, no offside lines to capture clear and obvious errors. However, without universal stadium readiness, even that remains challenging.
Comparisons Abroad: The UEFA Women’s Champions League will use full VAR from the league phase onwards starting in 2025/26. It already employs semi-automated offside (SAOT) and goal-line technology (GLT). The WSL, meanwhile, still relies solely on human decisions despite games increasingly being played in major stadiums like the Emirates and Stamford Bridge.
Training and Consistency: Even if VAR were introduced tomorrow, it would only work with proper investment in referee training. As this match proved, technology alone won’t solve the issue of consistency and accountability will.
Who’s Really to Blame?
Some Arsenal fans were quick to accuse Chelsea of “buying the ref,” but that misses the point entirely. The problem isn’t Chelsea, it's the league’s leadership and priorities.
The WSL’s new owners have spent heavily on marketing and rebranding, but little on officiating, infrastructure, or technology. Fans were promised a “new era” of professionalism, yet basic officiating standards remain the league’s weakest link.
If VAR had been in use, Pelova would almost certainly have been sent off, Arsenal’s first goal might have stood, and McCabe’s challenge on Bronze would have been reviewed. Instead, both teams were left short-changed by avoidable errors.
The money spent on logos and image updates would have been better invested in the fundamentals, better referees, matchday infrastructure, and player safety. The WSL is growing rapidly, but unless the league’s governance catches up, the credibility of its competition will keep being questioned.
Chelsea remain unbeaten, Arsenal remain frustrated, and fans across the league are once again talking more about referees than football. Until investment and accountability are prioritised, moments like these will continue to define matches instead of the brilliance on the pitch.
Final Score: Arsenal 1–1 Chelsea
Goals: Thompson (9’) – Russo (78’)
Player of the Match: Alyssa Thompson (Chelsea)
Chelsea equal the WSL record for longest unbeaten run (33 matches), while Arsenal leave the Emirates feeling hard done by. The football was superb but the officiating reminded everyone how far the league still has to go.
Add comment
Comments