Chelsea’s hopes of another trip to Wembley were shattered in one of the most chaotic and controversial FA Cup semi-finals in recent memory as Manchester City fought back from two goals down to win 3-2 after extra time at Stamford Bridge.
The afternoon began with several notable pre-match talking points. Hannah Hampton returned to Chelsea’s starting XI after being rested during the club’s 3-1 victory over Leicester City that secured Champions League qualification. Meanwhile, Sjoeke Nüsken marked her 100th appearance for Chelsea.
Manchester City also arrived with a surprise. Ayaka Yamashita travelled with the squad but was not named in the matchday squad, leaving Khiara Keating to start in goal.
Chelsea exploded into the game immediately. Within the opening minute Keating was forced into a superb save, stretching at full reach to tip a dangerous effort over the crossbar. It set the tone for an electric opening period dominated by the home side.
By the third minute Lauren James was already tormenting City’s defence, driving past Kerstin Casparij before aiming toward the top-right corner, only for Keating to save comfortably. James then attempted to catch the goalkeeper off her line from nearly 40 yards out with a fizzing effort that Keating tipped up before gathering.
City’s first dangerous moment came in the fifth minute when Lauren Hemp burst down the wing and flashed a dangerous cross across the face of goal, but no City player could arrive in time for the tap-in.
Chelsea’s intensity eventually brought the opening goal. Erin Cuthbert began the move herself with a delicate dinked ball toward Sam Kerr inside the area. After a scramble and several ricochets, the ball fell kindly to Cuthbert on the edge of the box. Her effort was initially heading toward the far corner before taking a heavy deflection off Jade Rose and spinning into the opposite side of the goal.
Chelsea thought they had doubled the lead shortly after in one of the game’s biggest controversies. Ellie Carpenter reached the byline and cut the ball back for Kerr to tap into an empty net. City players stopped immediately, convinced the ball had gone out of play before Carpenter crossed it. The assistant referee agreed and raised the flag.
The replay angles sparked huge debate. One angle suggested the ball had stayed in play, while another was less conclusive. Without VAR or goal-line technology available, Chelsea were left furious. Kerr herself looked convinced the ball had not crossed the line. It became one of the defining moments of the afternoon.
Chelsea continued to overwhelm City during the opening stages. The visitors looked rattled and stunned after conceding. Andrée Jeglertz cut an unusually frustrated figure on the touchline, visibly agitated whenever his side gave the ball away, including one moment involving Grace Clinton losing possession cheaply.
Another Chelsea opportunity followed when James drifted inside into a central position — always a dangerous sight for opposition goalkeepers. City survived after the ball ricocheted awkwardly before eventually falling to Leila Ouahabi, whose weak effort was comfortably collected by Hampton.
City slowly began finding moments in transition. In the 22nd minute Kerolin fired wastefully wide despite finding space in a promising area. It was a poor finish and she knew it immediately.
Still, Chelsea’s front three continued to terrorise City. James, Kerr and Alyssa Thompson constantly stretched the defensive line with clever movement and direct running. Thompson in particular was outstanding during the first half, repeatedly driving at defenders and forcing City backwards.
The 27th minute brought City’s biggest chance of the half. Khadija Shaw connected with a dangerous cross from Kerolin, but on her very first touch she completely lost control of the chance and skied the effort high over the bar. Vivianne Miedema’s absence due to personal reasons suddenly felt enormous — she was exactly the type of composed finisher City needed in that moment.
Chelsea continued creating chances. Thompson nearly wriggled through inside the area before Jade Rose stretched brilliantly to dispossess her. Soon after, Thompson delivered another dangerous cross toward Kerr, whose looping header drifted over the crossbar.
At the other end Hemp produced a beautiful looping delivery toward Shaw, but the Jamaican striker’s header also lacked power and sailed over.
The game then produced one of its finest goalkeeping moments. Laura Blindkilde Brown struck from distance and the effort took a wicked late deflection toward the top corner. Hampton reacted magnificently, adjusting her feet before springing left to palm the ball away. It was an elite save that required both anticipation and athleticism.
Late in the half Shaw went down after a collision and initially appeared frustrated when play continued. She briefly got back to her feet before going down again once the ball went out of play. Medical staff carried out concussion checks due to concerns around her neck and possible whiplash symptoms.
As Shaw received treatment, sections of the Chelsea crowd taunted her with chants of “We’ll see you next year,” creating a hostile atmosphere before halftime.
The second half began with another worrying collision. Hemp and Ouahabi attacked the same dropping ball and smashed into each other heavily. Hemp suffered a bloody nose and required lengthy treatment before leaving the pitch to change shirts. When she returned, she was bizarrely wearing a blank shirt without a name or number on the back after tissues had been packed into her nose to stop the bleeding.
It was exactly the sort of incident England manager Sarina Wiegman would not have wanted to witness involving one of her key international players.
Chelsea should have extended their lead in the 55th minute during an extraordinary goalmouth scramble. Kerr headed the ball down inside the six-yard box and somehow saw both her header and follow-up effort cleared off the line as City desperately scrambled bodies behind the ball.
Kerr finally got the goal she deserved soon after. James whipped a dangerous cross into the area which Keating appeared set to collect comfortably, only for the goalkeeper to spill the ball completely. Kerr reacted quickest, nodding into an empty net for yet another FA Cup goal.
The Australian could easily have had a hat-trick by the 68th minute. Cuthbert produced a sublime chipped pass over the defence and Kerr finished beautifully with a header into the corner, but this time the offside flag correctly ruled the goal out. Even so, it was another reminder of Chelsea’s attacking dominance.
City suddenly found a route back into the contest through Mary Fowler. After Shaw repeatedly tried to force an opening inside the area, the ball eventually broke kindly for Fowler on the edge of the box. She took one look up before curling brilliantly across Hampton into the far corner for her first goal since 2025.
The momentum of the game shifted sharply from there.
Chelsea’s decision to substitute Kerr and James proved hugely significant. Without the movement, creativity and constant threat of those two players, City suddenly looked far more comfortable defensively and began throwing bodies forward.
Then came the dramatic equaliser.
Deep into stoppage time, in the 92nd minute despite only seven additional minutes being shown, City finally found parity. The move began with outstanding work from Iman Beney, whose strength and balance with her back to goal created the opening. Shaw then produced a brilliant finish, swivelling and striking without even needing to look at the target.
The striker immediately sprinted toward the travelling fans, knee-sliding in celebration. Given her earlier treatment and the crowd chants aimed in her direction, there was extra emotion in the moment.
Those earlier disallowed Chelsea goals suddenly loomed enormous.
Extra time began with immediate controversy. Chelsea screamed for a penalty after Keating rushed out while challenging Aggie Beever-Jones following an awkward ricochet in the area. It was incredibly difficult to determine who touched the ball first, but the referee awarded City a free-kick instead, leaving Chelsea furious once again.
The decisive moment arrived in the 103rd minute.
Hampton attempted to play out from a goal kick but her pass was intercepted by Yui Hasegawa. The Japanese midfielder immediately delivered a cross into the area where Shaw powered a header into the far corner.
From two goals down, City led 3-2.
It was a devastating error from Hampton after an otherwise excellent performance and completely changed the complexion of the tie. Shaw’s celebration said everything. The comeback was complete.
Chelsea pushed desperately for another equaliser but never truly regained their earlier rhythm. Their attacking substitutions and missed opportunities had ultimately cost them.
The final attendance at Stamford Bridge was 7,773.
City were undoubtedly fortunate at times. Chelsea had the ball in the net multiple times, dominated large portions of the game and could easily argue they should have scored four goals. The absence of VAR and goal-line technology became a huge talking point afterward.
Yet City also showed resilience, character and clinical finishing in the decisive moments. Fowler’s impact changed the momentum, Shaw delivered under pressure, and Chelsea’s inability to kill the game allowed the comeback to happen.
Analysis
Chelsea controlled the match for nearly an hour because of the fluidity and movement of their front three. Kerr occupied the centre-backs, James drifted into dangerous half-spaces, and Thompson constantly attacked defenders directly. City struggled badly with runners in behind and looked uncomfortable whenever Chelsea accelerated transitions.
The biggest tactical issue for City in the first half was spacing between midfield and defence. Cuthbert repeatedly found pockets outside the area, while James continuously received the ball facing forward. Without Miedema, City also lacked composure in attacking moments. Shaw was isolated early and several attacks broke down due to rushed finishing or poor decision-making.
However, City’s resilience kept them alive.
The introduction of belief following Fowler’s goal completely changed the emotional energy of the game. Chelsea suddenly became hesitant, while City grew more aggressive physically and mentally.
Chelsea’s substitutions also altered the balance. Removing Kerr and James reduced their ability to relieve pressure through possession and direct attacking play. Without those outlets, City were able to push higher and sustain attacks.
The game also highlighted the ongoing debate around officiating technology in women’s football. Chelsea had two goals ruled out, one especially controversial, and the absence of VAR or goal-line confirmation heavily influenced the narrative afterward.
For City, Shaw’s performance summed up their comeback. She endured injuries, frustration, missed opportunities and crowd taunts, yet still delivered the two most important goals of the afternoon.
For Chelsea, it was a painful lesson in game management. They were the better side for long periods, but elite knockout football punishes missed chances and lapses in concentration.
Manchester City now head to Wembley for their first FA Cup final in four years, where Brighton await on May 31, and the dream of a remarkable double remains alive.
Add comment
Comments